Billy Corgan Wonders If Kanye West Took Inspiration From His Approach To Fame

TL;DR

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
• Member-only deals all year

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

Billy Corgan said on Popcast that Kanye West’s use of provocation reminded him of his own approach to public attention and artistic reputation. Corgan wondered whether West drew inspiration from him, but also said their similarities could have come from the broader culture; he described their direct contact as one friendly phone call.

Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan said on Popcast that he has wondered whether Kanye West took inspiration from his approach to fame, after noticing similarities in how they used provocation to influence public conversations about their art. Corgan raised the possibility, but did not claim to know that West was influenced by him; he said the similarities may simply have been “in the water.”

The exchange came after Popcast host Jon Caramanica told Corgan, “I hear a lot of Kanye in you,” according to Consequence’s account of the interview. Corgan replied, “Isn’t it the other way around? Didn’t I come first?” He recalled that while the Smashing Pumpkins were making Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, West was working at a Gap store “one block down the street.” Corgan said he did not know West then, but heard about his rise in Chicago.

Corgan said West’s public approach later struck him as familiar. “When I first saw his game, I thought … was he influenced by the way I did this shit?” he said. He described the perceived common tactic as picking fights and doing provocative things, which he said can prompt audiences to reassess both the artist and the work.

Corgan called this a “cognitive dissonance game”: controversy, in his account, can force people to decide how they value an artist. He said he saw West doing something similar by inviting judgments over whether he was a genius or an idiot. Those are Corgan’s interpretations of their public personas, not evidence that West consciously borrowed a strategy from him.

How Provocation Shapes an Artist’s Reputation

Corgan’s comments offer a veteran musician’s account of how controversy can become part of an artist’s public identity, rather than remaining separate from the work. In his view, a provocative act can shift attention toward a larger argument about whether the artist deserves acclaim or criticism. That framing helps explain why public disputes and unconventional behavior can remain central to conversations about musicians’ careers.

The remarks also illustrate the limits of drawing conclusions from perceived similarities. Corgan identifies what he sees as a shared method, but his account does not establish a direct line of influence. The distinction matters: similar tactics do not prove borrowing, particularly when the artists have had little direct contact.

Corgan’s Mellon Collie-Era Comparison

Corgan placed his comparison in the period when the Smashing Pumpkins were making Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, the album at the center of the band’s ongoing Rats in a Cage Tour, which celebrates its 30th anniversary. His recollection of West working nearby is a detail about the two artists’ proximity in Chicago; Corgan said they had not met at that point.

According to the report, Corgan said his direct contact with West amounts to a friendly phone call of about 15 minutes. That limited connection is relevant to his speculation: he described recognizing a resemblance in their public strategies, not learning from West or discussing the approach with him at length.

“Isn’t it the other way around? Didn’t I come first?”

— Billy Corgan, responding to Popcast host Jon Caramanica

No Evidence of Direct Artistic Influence

It is not clear whether West was influenced by Corgan. The source report provides Corgan’s impression and speculation, but no statement from West confirming that he took cues from the Smashing Pumpkins singer. Corgan himself left open the possibility that the approach was circulating more broadly rather than passing from one artist to the other.

The report also does not give a date for the phone call or further details about what the two discussed. Their limited contact, as Corgan described it, does not settle whether West encountered or consciously adopted Corgan’s public tactics.

Tour Continues as the Album Turns 30

The immediate context for Corgan revisiting his career is the Smashing Pumpkins’ Rats in a Cage Tour, marking 30 years since Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. The source report does not specify upcoming dates or announce a new development involving West. Further information about the artists’ views or any direct influence would require additional comments from West or other independently documented evidence.

Key Questions

Did Billy Corgan say Kanye West copied his approach?

No. Corgan wondered whether West may have been influenced by his approach, but presented it as speculation and said the similarities might have been “in the water.”

What similarities did Corgan describe?

He pointed to provocation and public controversy as ways of prompting audiences to debate an artist’s work and decide how to value the artist.

Have Corgan and West had much contact?

Corgan said they had little direct contact and described their only conversation as a friendly phone call lasting about 15 minutes.

Why did Corgan mention the Gap?

He recalled that while the Smashing Pumpkins were making Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, West was working at a Gap store nearby in Chicago. Corgan said he did not know West at the time.

What is the Rats in a Cage Tour?

It is the Smashing Pumpkins’ ongoing tour celebrating the 30th anniversary of Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, according to the source report.

Source: rss